Evaluating Poverty-Environment Dynamics

Edward Carr, University of South Carolina
Nathan Kettle, University of South Carolina
A. Hoskins, University of South Carolina

Abstract

Developing indicators to more effectively evaluate poverty-environment dynamics and inform policy is an urgent research priority. It is critical that these indicators are used in ways that accurately represent the relationship they are meant to inform. This article evaluates the theory and use of poverty-environment indicators, a relatively new tool developed to aid in the design and evaluation of poverty reduction strategies in the context of environmental change. We argue that while they have great potential, in their current form and use, poverty-environment indicators may contribute to critical misunderstandings of processes on the ground. These issues stem from a problematic and largely unacknowledged process of simplifying particular poverty-environment relationships. This article lays out the problematic character of this simplification process, and suggests how we might address these problems to create more useful understandings of poverty-environment dynamics to inform policy. © 2009 Taylor & Francis.