Geography

The law is not enough: Seeking the theoretical ‘frontier of urban justice’ via legal tools

Document Type

Article

Abstract

This commentary examines the conceptual limits of urban justice through the use of legal tools, both generally and in actually existing neoliberal urban contexts. Our interest emerges from previous research on social service siting in a region with legal tools that seem exceptionally friendly to spatial justice due to limits on exclusionary zoning. Conceptually, such powerful legal levers might be expected to mitigate the generally observed tendency towards revanchism in contexts of urban government devolution. However, even given exceptional legal accommodations, we found a spatially concentrated service landscape, mirroring neoliberal market-led framings of ‘highest and best use’. Using this prior research as a point of departure, we highlight related findings in the broader literature on the use of the law by urban social justice activists. We argue that even maximally powerful legal protections for justice-oriented actors cannot blunt systematic spatio-political dynamics that lead marketised states towards revanchist outcomes. We call for future research which more explicitly charts the specific frontiers of the potential of the law as a tool for social justice.

Publication Title

Urban Studies

Publication Date

2017

Volume

54

Issue

2

First Page

456

Last Page

465

ISSN

0042-0980

DOI

10.1177/0042098016636574

Keywords

critical urban geographies, devolution, law, legal geographies, social justice

Link to Full Text

Share

COinS